When you think of Cape Cod, visions of water, sandy beaches, and fresh seafood come to mind. If you are interested in visiting Cape Cod, you should consider Cape Cod vacation rentals from Leighton Realty. Leighton Realty specializes in offering exceptional Cape Cod rentals for your specific needs. While you are visiting Cape Cod, indulge in the deliciousness that is fresh Maine lobster. The following are the top five places where you can enjoy Cape Cod lobster rolls.


Sesuit Harbor Cafe

Discover Sesuit Harbor Café, a family-owned and operated business offering breakfast, lunch, and dinner. You’ll enjoy dining here as they serve up great Maine seafood with a view of the Cape Cod Bay and Northside Marina. At Sesuit Harbor Cafe, lobster rolls are one of the most popular items on the menu. Come here to enjoy delicious, succulent pieces of lobster placed in a sandwich roll with all the fixings.

The cafe also offers a number of other delicious menu items including lobster crab cakes, tuna sashimi, Lobster Bisque and much more! There is also a Raw Bar for those of you that want to enjoy the fresh taste of Maine seafood. Once you’ve had your fill of a delicious lobster roll, enjoy the treats from the bakery, courtesy of the in-house baker.

357 Sesuit Neck Rd
Dennis, MA 02638
(508) 385-6134


Chatham Pier Fish Market

If you are looking for some of the best Cape Cod lobster rolls, you’ve found them at Chatham Pier Fish Market. The lobster rolls here were actually featured in New England Today and even deemed the best lobster rolls on Cape Cod by Serious Eats. Hand-made fresh daily, these lobster rolls are worth the trip to this fish market.

Lobster rolls are just the beginning when it comes to the offerings at Chatham Pier Fish Market. They sell live and cooked lobsters as well as other fresh seafood, fish, and shellfish. You can have your fresh fish cleaned, cut, and fried right on the spot! If you enjoy smoked fish, they’ve got that too!

If you are feeling fancy, you can head over to Chatham’s sister restaurant, Bluefin’s Sushi & Sake Bar for gourmet sushi and cocktails.

45 Barcliff Avenue Ext,
Chatham, MA 02633
(508) 945-3474


Arnolds’s Lobster & Clam Bar

Come to the lobster and clam bar that has been serving up some of the best lobster rolls on Cape Cod for the past 40 years. Arnold’s is an award-winning clam shack that has something for all seafood lovers. Whether you are looking for the freshest raw or fried seafood, they’ve got you covered.

The lobster rolls, as well as the other seafood options here, are affordably priced and simply delicious. The clams here were named “the best in the world” by Food & Wine Magazine. If you’ve got a taste for something other than seafood, Arnold’s also serves foot-long hotdogs, chowder and their popular 50s Angus burger.

3580 Route 6
Eastham, MA 02642



Since 1957, people have been telling each other to “Meet Me at Baxter’s” for the best lobster rolls and seafood in Cape Cod. A family-owned establishment, this casual seafood restaurant is a mainstay in Cape Cod. Here you’ll get the freshest lobster rolls and other seafood items as well as burgers, salads, and specialty cocktails.

At Baxter’s, you’ll get to enjoy your lobster with a view of the Hyannis Harbor where boaters pull in throughout the day to drop off their bounties from the sea.

177 Pleasant St
Hyannis, MA 02601


The Chart Room

The Chart Room is a seasonal restaurant serving up delicious lobster rolls and other seafood delights during the spring and fall weekends and daily from the last week of June through Labor Day. The restaurant closes for the season on Columbus Day. If you are looking for the freshest seafood near your Brewster rentals, The Chart Room is the place to visit.

Visiting The Chart Room is an experience in itself. With the piano bar for entertainment as well as the welcoming casual environment, this is an excellent place to stop by and enjoy a lobster roll with a drink while enjoying the beautiful Cape Cod sunset.

For more information on all of Cape Cod’s lobster roll options and our nearby rentals, contact us today!

1 Shipyard Lane
Cataumet, MA 02534
(508) 563-5350